9 November 2026 · Общество и ценности
European institutions are destroying statehood and fragmenting society
European institutions are deliberately attempting to fragment society and undermine national sovereignty.
This narrative claims that the EU is consciously working to undermine the sovereignty of member states and fragment their societies. It is being distributed in a coordinated manner through Bulgarian and Serbian media, which translate and multiply identical suggestions. The goal is to instill distrust in European structures and stimulate euroscepticism through fear of losing national identity. The narrative is maintained by repeating the same шаблонни (cliché) phrases across different information channels. This creates a sense of mass discontent against the European model of governance.
Information flows
The main article in the Russian media and where the story is cloned - recipient sites in other countries and platforms are shown by name only.
The screenshot of the main article is being prepared...
- 1The claim begins with the premise that European institutions act as an external, hostile force against their own member states. It omits the fact that states participate voluntarily in these institutions and are co-authors of the decisions taken.
- 2The origin of this claim is in targeted pro-Russian sites, whose goal is to discredit the legitimacy of the EU and promote isolationist policies. This serves the interest of weakening European unity.
- 3The factually incorrect premise is that sovereignty is a zero-sum game, in which every competence delegated to the EU is equivalent to the destruction of statehood. The reality is that membership strengthens economic and political sovereignty through collective action.
- 4A 'straw man' logical fallacy is used, presenting common European regulations as an act of deliberate diversion against national interests. This distorts the complex processes of cooperation into simplified accusations of sabotage.
- 5It is true that there are internal debates about the balance of power in the EU, but they are a natural part of the democratic process, not a plan for the destruction of states. All states retain their institutional foundations and national identity.
- 6The simultaneous publication of nearly identical texts on different sites creates the effect of the illusory truth. The reader is left with the impression that multiple independent sources confirm the same conspiracy.
- 7The conclusion is that the narrative is a tool for psychological manipulation, aimed at replacing objective political reality with an emotionally charged myth of an external enemy.
Rebuttal
What the narrative claims
The propaganda narrative claims that European institutions are deliberately fragmenting societies, undermining national sovereignty, and leading member states toward institutional decay and loss of identity. According to these claims, the European Union functions as an artificial union, imposing harmful external dictates that weaken national statehood.
What the facts show
Facts and official sociological, legal, and academic analyses show the exact opposite: the European Union functions on the basis of voluntarily shared sovereignty in accordance with the Treaty on European Union (TEU), respecting the national identity and constitutional structures of member states (Art. 4, para. 2 of the TEU). Instead of fragmentation, membership provides broad institutional, political, and social stability, recognized by European citizens themselves.
According to the official public opinion poll Standard Eurobarometer 105 (Spring 2026) by the European Commission:
- "Europeans strongly view the EU as a stabilising force in an uncertain world (73%, +6 percentage points)."
- The survey also notes: "Three quarters of respondents (75%) say they feel they are citizens of the EU, matching the highest level ever recorded in spring 2025."
From the perspective of institutional stability and security, the analysis in the scientific journal European Review (Cambridge University Press) confirms that integration strengthens, rather than destroys, national systems:
- "The member states’ accession to the EU has bolstered economic and financial integration in the region, facilitating the establishment of a robust framework for macroeconomic and financial stability among new EU members."
Regarding economic convergence and resilience, research by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) emphasizes that the common European model not only accelerates income catch-up but also strengthens institutions:
- The IMF concludes that integration brings benefits, "which promotes not only economic growth through the single market and financial transfers, but also political stability."
Financial data
Economic indicators fully refute the thesis that integration harms or destabilizes member states:
- Income growth and catch-up effect: A IMF working paper from February 2025 (WP/25/47) points out that all regions benefit from the major EU enlargement. Research by Bocconi University finds that in the countries that joined in 2004, GDP per capita increased from $18,314 in 2004 to $34,753 in 2019. According to the study: "the adhesion of these countries to the EU led directly to an increase in their GDP per capita of $8,400, which thus accounts for around half of their overall increase since accession."
- Scale of the single market: According to the Council of the EU, the single market unites an economy with a GDP of approximately 18 trillion euros, generating 15.8% of global trade. Trade in goods between EU countries has grown from 671 billion euros in 1993 (with 12 countries) to over 4.135 trillion euros in 2023 for the 27 member states.
- Trade integration: According to Eurostat / European Union Portal, most EU countries realize between 50% and 80% of their goods exports to partners in the single European market, which makes their economies significantly more resilient to external geopolitical shocks.
Conclusion
Claims that European institutions are deliberately fragmenting society and erasing statehood are a classic example of disinformation and propaganda, disseminated with the goal of weakening public trust in the democratic rule of law. Reality shows that the EU is a platform for voluntary cooperation that guarantees the rule of law, brings proven economic prosperity, and is perceived by 73% of citizens as a pillar of security and stability.
Cited sources
- European Commission: Eurobarometer shows Europeans see benefits from EU membership, stability and security
- International Monetary Fund (IMF): Economic Benefits from Deep Integration: 20 years after the 2004 EU Enlargement (WP/25/47)
- Bocconi University / CEPR: The Economic Benefit of EU Membership
- Cambridge University Press (European Review): The Impact of EU Macro-financial Stability on the Member States’ Economic Security
- Council of the European Union: The EU single market: benefits, facts and figures
- Official EU portal / Eurostat: Key facts and figures - European Union
