All narratives

16 November 2026 · Украйна и войната

The West invents the Russian threat for political purposes

High risk

Western countries deliberately exaggerate the threat from Russia to serve their geopolitical interests and justify militarization.

This narrative claims that Western states are fabricating the myth of a 'Russian threat' in order to justify military spending, save the ratings of their politicians, or manipulate public opinion. The campaign is spread in a coordinated manner through Russian state media such as RIA Novosti, Vzglyad, and EADaily, being translated and published simultaneously in Bulgarian pro-Russian media. The goal is to undermine confidence in the collective security of NATO and the EU. The repetition of the same claim in different sources creates a false sense of consensus. This serves Russian foreign policy by weakening Western unity.

Share:

Information flows

The main article in the Russian media and where the story is cloned - recipient sites in other countries and platforms are shown by name only.

The screenshot of the main article is being prepared...

PRIMARY SOURCE · RUSSIAria.ruНа Западе признали, что нагнетание страхаперед Россией выгодно для НАТОpogled.inforecipient site · Bulgaria×6vz.rurecipient site · other countryeadaily.comrecipient site · other countryglobalresearch.carecipient site · Canadatheduran.comrecipient site · USAles-crises.frrecipient site · Franceinfobrics.orgrecipient site · other country×4
  1. 1It is claimed that the threat is a figment of 'Western elites', while completely ignoring the real actions of Russia that led to the strengthening of NATO's defense. The hidden premise is that sovereign states have no right to defend themselves against aggressive foreign policy.
  2. 2The claim originates directly from Russian state media that aim to delegitimize European security efforts. The main goal is to present defensive measures as aggression.
  3. 3The factually incorrect premise is that Russia is not a threat, despite official documents and military operations. This is easily refutable through historical data on territorial claims and the actions of the Russian army.
  4. 4The 'straw man' fallacy is used, where the Alliance's actions are presented as a thirst for war in order to hide the defensive nature of those actions. There is also an 'appeal to fear' aiming to convince citizens that their governments are leading them into conflict.
  5. 5The truth according to facts is that the militarization of Europe is a direct reaction to Russian aggression against Ukraine. This is a predictable and transparent reaction of democratic alliances to preserve peace.
  6. 6The repetition of this narrative by different media simultaneously uses the 'illusory truth effect', where readers start to accept the thesis simply because they have heard it from many sources. This masks the lack of evidence.
  7. 7The conclusion is that the narrative is an instrument of psychological warfare aiming for the paralysis of Western societies in the face of a real threat.
Primary source: ria.ru (Russia)

Rebuttal

What the narrative claims

The narrative claims that EU and NATO countries are deliberately fabricating and exaggerating an imaginary "Russian threat" to justify militarization, drastic increases in defense budgets, control over public opinion, and saving the falling ratings of Western politicians. According to propaganda sources, Russian aggression is a fictional geopolitical tool of the West, aimed at artificially whipping up fear among European citizens.

What the facts show (with direct quotes)

Reality categorically refutes the thesis of an "invented" threat. The military danger from the Russian Federation is a documented material fact - an unprovoked full-scale invasion of a sovereign European state, systematic violations of international law, and a large-scale campaign of hybrid attacks against European states.

  1. NATO's official position and chronology: In the official institutional analysis "Setting the record straight", NATO Topic, published on November 11, 2025, the Alliance states verbatim: "NATO is a defensive alliance. Allies work together to deter aggression and to ensure that NATO is prepared to defend all Allies in case of attack. NATO does not seek confrontation and poses no threat to Russia, or any other nation. NATO did not invade Georgia in 2008. Russia did. NATO did not invade Ukraine in 2014, and again in 2022. Russia did." Regarding claims of prior militarization of the eastern flank, NATO explicitly emphasizes: "Before Russia's aggressive actions against Ukraine in 2014, there was no permanent deployment of multinational NATO troops in the eastern part of the Alliance."

  2. European External Action Service (EEAS): In the official report "2024 Report on EEAS Activities to Counter Foreign Information Manipulation and Interference (FIMI)", adopted on August 21, 2025, EU institutions note Moscow's coordinated attempts to substitute reality: "In 2024, the prime target for Russia’s FIMI operations continued to be Ukraine with attempts to undermine its legitimacy, jeopardize the international support for the government and people... This includes attempts to swing international opinion to legitimising Russia’s war of aggression, derail and distract focus from Russia’s attacks on civilian targets, infrastructure, Russian forces’ war crimes and wanton destruction."

  3. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD): In the report "Assessing the Impact of Russia’s War against Ukraine on Eastern Partner Countries", OECD, published on January 20, 2023, analysts state: "Russia’s war of aggression against Ukraine is a human tragedy on a scale not seen in decades in Europe, with tens of thousands dying and millions of refugees escaping Ukraine or being internally displaced."

  4. Analysis of hybrid warfare by the Congressional Research Service (CRS): In the report "Russian Hybrid Warfare Activities in Europe: Considerations for Congress", Library of Congress from August 11, 2026, it is stated: "Following Russia's invasion of Ukraine in 2022, U.S. and European officials have accused Russia of a sustained campaign of malign activities, often referred to as hybrid warfare, across Europe. These attacks, which have been increasing in number and severity, include sabotage, assassinations, political interference and influence, cyberattacks, and airspace violations, among others."

  5. Specialized centers for strategic communications: In the study by the Swedish Institute of International Affairs "Narrating Disinformation: The Templates for Kremlin Lies", Utrikespolitiska institutet, based on the mapped 13,000+ disinformation cases by the EU's East StratCom task force, it is proven that the storyline "Western elites manipulate the people with invented enemies" is a standard Kremlin matrix template used systematically to undermine democratic societies.

Financial data

Claims that the threat is economically or politically beneficial for European countries are shattered by official macroeconomic analyses of the European Commission and the European Council:

  • Direct losses for EU growth: According to the official macroeconomic study of the European Commission's Directorate-General for Economic and Financial Affairs "The cost of EU Member States’ proximity to the war", European Commission, published on November 17, 2025, geographic proximity to Russian aggression has cost a significant decline in economic dynamism: for the 2022-2023 period, the net loss in annual GDP growth for the affected member states is estimated at approximately 2 percentage points (pps), accompanied by a sharp spike in energy and food inflation.
  • Blocked resources and sanctions: According to data from the Council of the EU ("Impact of sanctions on the Russian economy"), as a result of the real aggression, over 300 billion euros of Russian Central Bank assets have been frozen in the EU and G7 countries, and about 70% of the Russian banking system's assets have been placed under European sanctions. According to IMF and World Bank estimates, Russia's GDP shrank by 2.1% in 2022, and the country's imports fell by between 9.7% and 15.01%.

These data show that Russia's war brought severe inflationary shocks and a slowdown in growth to European economies, not dividends.

Conclusion

The thesis that the West "invents" the Russian threat is a classic projection and propaganda manipulation. European defense policy is not the root cause, but a forced, belated, and defensive response to materially proven acts of aggression: the 2014 annexation of Crimea, the 2022 full-scale invasion of Ukraine, the destruction of civilian infrastructure, and the sabotage and cyberattacks against EU and NATO states. The facts and economic parameters categorically prove that the Russian threat is a real event with a high cost for European citizens, not a PR tool of Western governments.

Cited sources

us versus themconspiracy thinkingappeal to fearfalse dilemma
anti-NATOanti-EUpro-Russianconspiratorial

Related narratives

TruthMeter is an automated disinformation radar: the system continuously scans Russian state media and the websites that republish their content, exposes the primary source of each coordinated propaganda story, tracks how it spreads across countries and languages, and produces factual rebuttals backed by independent sources such as Eurostat, the IMF and the World Bank.

© 2026 TruthMeter · A project fighting disinformation

Cookie settings

We use necessary cookies, without which the site cannot work, and optionally - statistics cookies (Google Analytics) that help us measure visits anonymously. You can change your choice at any time via "Cookie settings" in the footer.

Necessary

Required for the site to work. Always active.

Always active

Statistics (Google Analytics)

Anonymous visit data - helps us improve the site.