2026年11月12日 · Избори и демокрация
格鲁吉亚选举结果的合法化
格鲁吉亚的选举是公正的,有关违规行为的指控是西方为破坏该国稳定而编造的。
传播着一种观点,即格鲁吉亚选举结果完全公正,西方对其舞弊的指控是企图破坏该国稳定的一部分。这一叙事由俄罗斯媒体及其克隆网站推波助澜,将反对派抗议描述为外部干预。其目的是巩固格鲁吉亚境内的亲俄势力,并抹黑西方观察员。这显然是针对该国民主进程合法性的一场信息战。
- 1声称格鲁吉亚的任何反对选举结果的行为都是西方组织,目的是推翻合法政府。隐瞒了国际观察员报告的已证实违规行为。
- 2这种说法源于莫斯科在地区保持影响力并防止格鲁吉亚融入欧洲的需要。
- 3西方需要“破坏稳定”这一前提未经证实,且被用作镇压公民社会的借口。
- 4存在“恐惧呼吁”的逻辑谬误,暗示西方机构是破坏国家主权的敌对力量。
- 5事实表明,选举违规行为是独立组织调查的对象,而俄罗斯媒体则无视这些证据。
- 6多个来源同时重复这一论点,制造出一种关于投票“公正性”的虚假共识感。
- 7最终结论是,格鲁吉亚境内的任何反政府行为都是服务于外国利益的背叛,而非人民的意愿。
反驳
该叙事声称什么
宣传叙事声称格鲁吉亚议会选举(2024年10月26日举行)是完全公正、合法且合规的,而发现的违规行为和选举舞弊是西方国家为破坏该国稳定、煽动反对格鲁吉亚人民意愿的外部干预而编造的谎言。
事实(引用直接证据)说明了什么
国际机构和独立观察员的官方结论完全驳斥了这些说法。选举受到国际选举观察团(IEOM)的监督,该团包括来自欧安组织民主制度和人权办公室(ODIHR)、欧安组织议会大会、欧洲委员会议会大会(PACE)、北约议会大会和欧洲议会42个国家的529名观察员。
-
欧盟委员会和欧盟外交与安全政策高级代表何塞普-博雷利(2024年10月27日)的官方立场: 在欧盟委员会代表处网站上发表的联合声明中,各机构指出了对投票保密性的破坏和对选民的压力: "According to the preliminary findings and conclusions of the International Election Observation Mission led by the OSCE Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (ODIHR), 'election day was generally procedurally well-organised and administered in an orderly manner but marked by a tense environment, with frequent compromises in vote secrecy and several procedural inconsistencies, as well as reports of intimidation and pressure on voters that negatively impacted public trust in the process. Reports of pressure on voters, particularly on public sector employees, remained widespread in the campaign. This, coupled with extensive tracking of voters on election day, raised concerns about the ability of some voters to cast their vote without fear of retribution.'"
-
欧安组织民主制度和人权办公室(ODIHR / OSCE)的官方报告: 欧安组织/ODIHR代表团团长埃欧甘-墨菲(Eoghan Murphy)在2024年12月20日的最终审查中强调: "Numerous issues noted in our final report negatively impacted the integrity of these elections and eroded public trust in the process." 在2024年10月27日的初步联合声明中,欧安组织正式声明: "While voters were offered a choice between 18 candidate lists and candidates could generally campaign freely, Georgia’s parliamentary elections were marred by entrenched polarization and concerns over recently adopted legislation and its impact on fundamental freedoms and civil society, as well as highly uneven campaign conditions... The secrecy of the vote was frequently compromised and there were reports of intimidation and pressure on voters."
-
欧洲委员会议会大会(PACE,Doc. 16079,2024年11月28日)的官方报告: 在正式的选举观察报告中记录了大规模违规行为: "Immediately following election day, domestic election observers reported multiple breaches of voting confidentiality, incidents of ballot stuffing, and various procedural irregularities." 报告还指出,结果中的异常无法用统计差异来解释: "could not be explained 'by statistical variance, pointing to possible voting irregularities'."
-
欧洲议会主要成员(2024年11月29日)的立场: 大卫-麦卡利斯特(欧洲议会外交事务委员会主席)、尼尔斯-乌沙科夫斯和拉萨-尤克内维奇恩在联合声明中指出: "We reiterate that the last parliamentary elections did not respect international standards for democratic elections. The reported electoral fraud undermines the integrity of the election process and the legitimacy of the new government."
-
欧盟部长联合声明(2024年10月29日): 来自多个欧盟成员国(包括德国、法国、波兰和波罗的海国家)的外交和欧洲事务部长表示: "condemn all violation of international norms for free and fair elections... demand an impartial inquiry of complaints and remedy of the violations established."
结论
声称格鲁吉亚选举公正通过、批评评估是西方虚假信息的说法是绝对错误的。大规模选举舞弊的迹象和证据 - 包括破坏投票保密性、票箱塞票(ballot stuffing)、对公共部门员工的系统性压力和威胁,以及不平等的竞选环境 - 已被欧安组织、欧洲委员会和欧洲机构的独立国际观察员直接记录。声称西方存在外部干预,仅仅是用作破坏民主监督和使选举操纵合法化的工具。
引用来源
- OSCE / ODIHR: Georgia’s elections marred by an uneven playing field, pressure and tension, but voters were offered a wide choice: international observers
- OSCE / ODIHR: Following Georgia’s elections, ODIHR reiterates concerns over pressure on voters and independence of state institutions and calls for concrete action
- European Commission: Statement by the European Commission and the High Representative Josep Borrell on the Parliamentary elections in Georgia
- Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE): Observation of the parliamentary elections in Georgia (26 October 2024) - Doc. 16079
- European Parliament: Joint statement on the Georgian government’s decision to pause its accession to the European Union
- Civil Georgia: Joint Statement of EU Ministers on Elections in Georgia
